So it's a bit hard to say for sure if you could have it. I don't know enough about the calculations on that. "The problem would be how stable a system is. "There's no reason why they couldn't, although nobody's ever detected one," he told the Daily Mail. Professor Martin Barstow in particular wonders if a planet could really survive near such a large black hole. Mat Kaplan goes on to equate the ship's miraculous propulsion to the sort of problem even "Star Trek" found a way to cleverly side-step. "Gene Rodenberry said he created transporters for 'Star Trek' because he didn't want to waste time getting to the surface and back. I think quite possibly a little bit of that was going on here as well, but it's certainly forgivable for telling a great story." We're happy to forgive Nolan for possibly using the miraculous propulsion as a means of expediting the action in 'Interstellar' (particularly in the context of the film's 2 hour and 49 minute runtime), but given his dedication to hard science in the film, it seems like he probably could've indulged a bit more in this particular time construct. I sure wish our Nasa had some of that fuel because we could go places a lot faster!" "The main thing that seemed unrealistic was whatever propulsion they had, to escape the extreme gravity wells of a planet that caused men to age a decade in an hour. Those things are going to be pouring off hard radiation from the super-heated material that piles up around the event horizon, and so it kind of seems a big stretch to think you can just blissfully glide over it and not melt." So it seems even if the film's black hole trip made for marvelously mind-melting cinema , more than just Cooper's mind would've melted in reality.īut while the craft itself is more than a realistic means of traversing open space, Lee Billings believes the ease with which Endurance and its detachable crafts take off from planets is more than a little bit problematic. "Endurance seems quite plausible, in terms of artificial gravity spinning around to give you that force that prevents bones from decaying in microgravity," he noted in his interview with the Daily Mail. "I think if astronauts ended up getting as close to the accretion disc around a supermassive black hole, as they did in the film, in reality they would have a bad time. Lee Billings takes matters further, explaining that radiation from a black hole would likely kill you before you ever actually got inside. Communicating out of one is also impossible." So there's no chance that anything or anybody could survive in a black hole. "The idea is that anything that falls into it becomes like spaghetti, stretched out by gravity. While the moment makes for grand storytelling and adds some truly astounding visual elements, per Professor Martin Barstow, there's absolutely no chance Cooper could have survived inside a black hole, let alone communicated with the outside world. "The gravitational field is extremely intense and changes very quickly," Barstow told the Daily Mail. "We have no idea if stable wormholes exist on a macroscopic scale." Real or not, the wormhole in "Interstellar" remains one of the film's most visceral and visually arresting creations. "Saying that we have to rely on borderline miracles of physics makes it easier, but also makes it way harder," Billings said. Lauded scientific author Lee Billings is a bit harsher in her criticism of wormhole theory, labeling the theoretical portals with the dreaded scientific term miracles. But, from a dramatic point of view you've got to have something like this in the film like that otherwise it doesn't work." We know about black holes, but the idea of something connecting different parts of space is very much an idea in its infancy. "There's no direct evidence such things exist in the universe. Explaining how one might work is really in the realm of science fiction," Barstow told the Daily Mail. Professor Martin Barstow of the Royal Astronomical Society was quick to point this fact out in his critique of the film's scientific accuracy, though he's also quick to acknowledge it's a solid storytelling device. "I don't think they really exist.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |